Reviews 4,000+ verified REVIEWS
Services
Pricing plans
Compare all plans
Tax guide
WhatsApp
Services
Pricing plans
Compare all plans
Tax Guide
Articles
All articles

Discrepancy

Money Magazine's tax test reveals an average discrepancy of over 300% in the amount that tax preparers state is due.

Since 1987, Money magazine has conducted a total of eight "tax tests" for the purpose of testing the knowledge and ability of tax preparers across the country. The test involved sending a financial profile of a hypothetical family to an average of 50 seasoned tax professionals, who agreed to use the data to complete the family`s tax return and then be judged by Money. The tax issues presented on the tests were fairly standard, and in the course of a filing season, the tax pros were bound to encounter most, if not all of them.

The table below tabulates the tax test results for all 8 years that the test was conducted:
Year of tax test Range of tax preparers' stated amount of tax due % Difference in stated amount Range of tax preparers' fees
1987 $7,202 - $11,881 165% $187 - $2,500
1988 $12,539 - $35,813 286% $250 - $2,200
1989 $9,806 - $21,216 216% $271 - $4,000
1990 $6,807 - $73,247 1076% $375 - $3,160
1991 $16,219 - $46,564 287% $520 - $4,500
1992 $31,846 - $74,450 234% $375 - $3,600
1996 $36,322 - $94,438 260% $300 - $4,950
1997 $34,240 - $68,912 201% not available

Overall result: There is an average discrepancy of over 300% in what these tax preparers state is due.