Not all tax paid in France is eligible for U.S. income tax purposes

Not all tax paid in France is eligible for U.S. income tax purposes
Ines Zemelman, EA
12 February 2018

If you ever took the SATs, you should be fairly familiar with analogies. If we were to ask - which of these does NOT apply.

Q: France: Romance

A. France: Fluffy croissants
B. France: World Class Museums
C. France: Beautiful Beaches & Mountains
D. France: High Taxation in the Eyes of the IRS.

Unlike the first three choices which are all synonymous with France, in the eyes of the IRS the 4th is not fully true. For U.S. Citizens & Green Card holders in France, what seems like high tax in French is mostly social contributions & not available for deduction as foreign tax credit.  How can it be that you pay 60+% in tax, but the IRS does not recognize it as such?

Social Contributions

For U.S. Tax purposes, ‘Contribution Sociale Généralisée” (CSG) and the “Contribution pour le Remboursement de la Dette Sociale” (CRDS) are not creditable or deductible taxes under the Internal Revenue Code or the U.S.-French Income Tax Treaty. These contributions do not reduce taxable income and cannot be applied as a deduction.

Unfair? That depends. The main reason that these are not eligible for deductions is that the premise is that you, as a resident of France, benefit from these social contributions. You receive healthcare, education, and other benefits that your Social contributions provide.

Wealth Tax - L'impôt de solidarité sur la fortune

French residents with assets in excess of €1,300,0000 face an additional “wealth tax” - known as ISF.  For U.S. tax purposes, this tax is not allowed as a foreign tax credit but can be deducted as a part of itemized deductions on U.S. tax returns.

Income Tax - L'impôt sur le revenue

This is the only part of French tax allowed for the Foreign Tax Credit on US tax return.

French Income Tax Rates

The tax rates and bands for 2017 (for 2016 income) are set out below.

There are five tax rates and bands on net taxable income, as follows:

 

Income Share

Tax Rate

Up to €9,710

0%

Between €9,711 - €26,818

14%

Between €26,819 - €71,898

30%

Between €71,899 - €152,260

41%

Above €151,261

45%

 

The amount of taxable income, or "revenu fiscal de référence" (RFR), is not equal to the income received by the household in the year. Instead, the RFR is determined by dividing the income by the number of "parts" in the fiscal household (1 part for every adult, 0.5 parts for each of the first two child, and 1 part for each successive child), and then diminished further by a standard deduction and any other deductions the taxpayer may have claimed in the year.

Thus, “Income share” is determined on net taxable income, after multiple deductions allowed in France - yet disregarded in the US.

As a result, cumulative Income and Social Security tax rates on income of $100K is 44%, while the effective income tax rate allowed for the foreign tax credit is only 20% - one of the lowest in the world.

KPMG's Individual Income Tax and Social Security Rate Survey 2012, KPMG International

Ines Zemelman, EA
founder of Taxes for Expats