OBBBA tax benefits – non-resident aliens disparity problem
The One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) creates an unintended two-tier benefits system where employees performing identical work receive vastly different tax treatment based solely on their immigration status and tax identification documentation.
NOTE! Identical work can result in tax savings differences of $3,000–$7,500 annually between similarly situated employees, creating significant workplace equity challenges for employers.
The core problem: Documentation-based disparity
SSN vs ITIN requirements
The OBBBA requires taxpayers to provide Social Security Numbers on their tax returns to claim the new deductions. This seemingly administrative requirement creates a fundamental divide:
- US Citizens and Permanent Residents: Possess SSNs and can claim deductions
- Non-Resident Aliens: Often have only ITINs and are categorically excluded from benefits
- Result: Identical work performance yields different after-tax compensation based solely on documentation status
Real-world impact scenarios
Scenario 1: Restaurant servers
The Setup: Two servers working identical shifts at the same upscale restaurant
Employee A - Maria (US Citizen)
- Hours: 40 hours/week, evening shifts
- Annual tip income: $30,000
- Tax benefit: Can deduct up to $25,000 in tips
- Annual tax savings: $6,000–$7,500
Employee B - Yuki (H-1B Visa Holder)
- Hours: 40 hours/week, identical shifts to Maria
- Annual tip income: $30,000 (same customer base, same service quality)
- Tax benefit: Cannot claim any tip deduction (ITIN holder)
- Annual tax savings: $0
Effective Hourly Rate Impact:
- Maria: $15.00/hour base + $14.40/hour in tips (after tax savings)
- Yuki: $15.00/hour base + $12.50/hour in tips (full tax burden)
- Disparity: Maria effectively earns $1.90 more per hour for identical work
Scenario 2: Software development team
The Setup: Two senior developers on the same project team working mandatory overtime
Developer A - James (Green Card Holder)
- Base salary: $120,000
- Overtime hours: 10 hours/week average
- Annual overtime premium: $15,000
- Tax benefit: Can deduct up to $12,500 in overtime premium
- Annual tax savings: $3,000–$4,500
Developer B - Raj (L-1 Visa Holder)
- Base salary: $120,000 (identical role and performance)
- Overtime hours: 10 hours/week average (same project deadlines)
- Annual overtime premium: $15,000
- Tax benefit: Cannot claim overtime deduction (ITIN holder)
- Annual tax savings: $0
Impact: Over the four-year period, James receives $12,000–$18,000 in additional after-tax income for performing identical work.
Scenario 3: Hospital medical staff
The Setup: Resident physicians in the same training program
Dr. Anderson (US Medical Graduate)
- Residency salary: $60,000
- Mandatory overtime: 20 hours/week
- Annual overtime premium: $18,000
- Tax benefit: Can deduct up to $12,500 in overtime
- Annual tax savings: $3,000–$4,500
Dr. Patel (J-1 Visa International Medical Graduate)
- Residency salary: $60,000 (standardized program compensation)
- Mandatory overtime: 20 hours/week (identical training requirements)
- Annual overtime premium: $18,000
- Tax benefit: Cannot claim overtime deduction
- Annual tax savings: $0
Cumulative financial impact analysis
Four-year duration effects
| Worker type | Annual disparity | Four-year total | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| High-tip service worker (Restaurant/Hotel) | $6,000–$7,500 | $24,000–$30,000 | Effective additional compensation for SSN holders |
| Regular overtime worker (Manufacturing/Healthcare) | $3,000–$4,500 | $24,000–$30,000 | Significant career earnings difference for identical work |
| Regular overtime worker (Manufacturing/Healthcare) | Up to $12,000 | Up to $48,000 | Substantial career-altering financial difference |
Percentage impact on take-home pay
For workers earning $40,000–$60,000 annually (common in affected industries):
- SSN holders: Effective 7.5–15% tax-free bonus
- ITIN holders: No benefit, bearing full tax burden
- Relative disadvantage: NRA employees effectively earn 7.5–15% less for identical work
Industry-specific disparity patterns
Technology sector: The H-1B problem
Approximately 85,000 H-1B visa holders are affected annually, many in overtime-eligible positions. Typical scenarios include software engineers working on critical project deadlines. IT professionals and data scientists are also impacted during system implementations and product launches.
Senior developers are losing $4,000–$6,000 annually in tax benefits despite performing identical work as their permanent resident colleagues.
Service industries: Tipped worker inequality
- Affected population: Hundreds of thousands of service workers on various visa types
- High-impact roles:
- Restaurant servers and bartenders
- Hotel concierge and room service staff
- Casino dealers and hospitality workers
- Personal service providers (hair stylists, massage therapists)
Healthcare: Training and professional disparities
International medical graduates, nurses, and healthcare technicians are affected. Residency programs often require mandatory overtime. Hospital staff face strain during critical shortages.
Traveling healthcare workers on temporary visas experience reduced effective compensation during crucial training periods, impacting professional development.
Seasonal and agricultural work
- Affected population: H-2A and H-2B temporary workers
- Seasonal disparities:
- Agricultural workers during harvest seasons
- Resort and hospitality workers during peak seasons
- Construction workers on temporary projects
Documentation and record-keeping requirements
- Employer Obligations: Employers must maintain clear records of tax status verification, document business justifications for any compensation adjustments, and ensure consistent application of policies across all employee groups.
- Best Practices: Companies should implement written policies explaining tax benefit limitations, provide training documentation for managers and HR staff, and conduct regular audits of compensation equity measures.
- Budget Planning Adjustments: Organizations need to factor compensation equity costs into financial planning, evaluate the total cost of employment for different worker classifications, and consider the ROI of retention efforts for experienced NRA employees.
- State and Local Responses: Some states may offer tax credits or deductions at the state level to help offset federal limitations.
Conclusion: The four-year window limitation
With the discussed OBBBA provisions set to expire after 2028, employers must balance the cost of addressing disparities against the temporary nature of the problem, while considering the potential for legislative extension or modification.
Taxes for Expats specializes in helping non-resident aliens and expats navigate complex US tax laws. If you're unsure how this disparity impacts your returns, our experts can guide you through compliance, deductions, and strategic planning.
We’ll guide you through it
